The Safety of Electric Cars in Fire Incidents: Lessons from the Toronto Tesla Crash

November 11, 2024, Kitchener, Ontario

Posted by: Robert Deutschmann, Personal Injury Lawyer

The tragic Tesla crash in Toronto on October 24, 2024, which claimed four lives and left one person seriously injured, has reignited discussions about the safety of electric vehicles (EVs) in fire incidents, particularly when door locks fail to disengage. This incident serves as a sobering reminder of the unique challenges posed by EV fires and the importance of understanding these risks.

The Toronto Tesla Crash: A Closer Look

In the early hours of October 24, a 2024 Tesla traveling at high speed on Lake Shore Boulevard East lost control, struck a guardrail, and collided with a concrete pillar[1][3]. The impact caused the vehicle to burst into flames, trapping five occupants inside. While one passenger was pulled to safety by a quick-thinking bystander, four others tragically lost their lives in the fiery wreck.

Electric Vehicle Fires: Unique Challenges

EV fires present distinct challenges compared to conventional gasoline-powered vehicle fires:

Intensity and Duration: EV fires can burn hotter and longer due to the nature of lithium-ion batteries[2]. In the Toronto incident, firefighters reported a "significant fire" that required special attention.

Battery Reignition: There's a risk of "thermal runaway," where damaged batteries can reignite even weeks after the initial fire. This necessitates special handling and disposal procedures for affected vehicles.

Water Requirements: Extinguishing EV fires often requires substantially more water than conventional car fires.

The Door Lock Dilemma

One of the most critical safety concerns in EV fires is the potential failure of electronic door locks. In high-impact collisions or severe electrical system damage, these locks may malfunction, trapping occupants inside. This issue isn't unique to EVs but can be exacerbated by the intense heat and electrical disruptions in EV fires.

Safety Measures and Recommendations

To address these concerns, several measures can be implemeted:

Manual Override Systems: Manufacturers should ensure robust manual override systems for electronic door locks, accessible even in severe crash scenarios.

Emergency Response Training: First responders need specialized training in handling EV fires, including techniques for rapid extrication of occupants.

Battery Design Improvements: Ongoing research into safer battery designs and fire-resistant materials is crucial for mitigating fire risks in EVs.

Public Education: EV owners should be educated about the unique risks associated with their vehicles and trained in emergency evacuation procedures.

The Role of Speed and Driver Behavior

While the focus often falls on vehicle design, it's crucial to note that the Toronto crash involved excessive speed. This underscores the importance of responsible driving, regardless of the vehicle type. Advanced safety features in EVs can only do so much to mitigate risks associated with reckless driving.

Balancing Innovation and Safety

The transition to electric vehicles is a crucial part of our efforts to combat climate change and reduce dependence on fossil fuels. However, incidents like the Toronto crash highlight the need for continuous improvement in EV safety technologies.

Manufacturers must prioritize safety features that address the unique challenges of EV fires, including improved battery containment systems and fail-safe door mechanisms. Regulatory bodies should also consider updating safety standards to reflect the specific risks associated with EVs.

Conclusion

The Toronto Tesla crash serves as a stark reminder of the ongoing need for vigilance in vehicle safety, particularly as we transition to new technologies. While EVs offer numerous benefits, including reduced emissions and lower operating costs, ensuring occupant safety in all scenarios must remain a top priority.

As we move forward, a collaborative effort between manufacturers, regulators, emergency services, and the public is essential to address these safety concerns effectively. By learning from tragic incidents like the Toronto crash and implementing robust safety measures, we can work towards a future where the benefits of electric vehicles are realized without compromising on safety.

If you or a loved one is injured because of being trapped in an EV contact one of our personal injury team today. Rob, Nick or Alexander are happy to meet with you to dicuss your case for free.

About Deutschmann Law

Deutschmann Law serves South-Western Ontario with offices in Kitchener-Waterloo, Cambridge, Woodstock, Brantford, Stratford and Ayr. The law practice of Robert Deutschmann focuses almost exclusively in personal injury and disability insurance matters. For more information, please visit www.deutschmannlaw.com or call us at 1-519-742-7774.

It is important that you review your accident benefit file with one of our experienced personal injury / car accident lawyers to ensure that you obtain access to all your benefits which include, but are limited to, things like physiotherapy, income replacement benefits, vocational retraining and home modifications.