Ontario Superior Court Rules on Social Media Disclosure Request in a Personal Injury Case - Mohamud v. Juskey, 2023 ONSC 4414

September 21, 2023, Kitchener, Ontario

Posted by: Robert Deutschmann, Personal Injury Lawyer

In the ever-evolving landscape of personal injury law, staying up-to-date with legal precedents and emerging trends can be challenging for both legal practitioners and individuals seeking justice. A recent ruling by the Ontario Superior Court has shed more light on the significance of social media in personal injury cases and the implications it can have on disclosure requests. In this blog post, we will explore the details of the case and its potential impact on the legal landscape of Ontario, Canada.

The Case at Hand

In Mohamud v. Juskey, 2023 ONSC 4414 a personal injury claimant who sustained injuries in a motor vehicle accident. As part of the litigation process, the defendant sought access to the claimant's social media accounts, arguing that the content posted there might be relevant to the case. This request raised important questions about privacy, relevance, and the scope of social media disclosure in the context of personal injury claims.

The Balancing Act: Privacy vs. Relevance

One of the central issues addressed by the Ontario Superior Court was the delicate balance between privacy rights and the relevance of social media content in a personal injury case. The claimant argued that their social media accounts contained private and personal information unrelated to the accident, and therefore, the request for access should be denied.

However, the court emphasized that when a party initiates a personal injury claim, they are essentially putting their physical and mental condition at the forefront of the dispute. This means that information on social media accounts, which can give insights into the claimant's lifestyle and activities, can be relevant in assessing the extent of their injuries and their impact on daily life.

Scope of Disclosure

In its ruling, the Ontario Superior Court stressed the importance of a balanced and proportionate approach to social media disclosure. It noted that a blanket request for access to all social media content would be overly invasive and infringe on privacy rights. Instead, the court encouraged parties to narrow their requests to specific timeframes and keywords that are directly related to the case.

This approach underscores the need for lawyers to carefully craft disclosure requests ensuring that they target only the information that is genuinely pertinent to the case. It also serves as a reminder to anyone involved in personal injury claims to exercise caution when posting on social media during ongoing litigation, as their content could be subject to scrutiny.

Relevance and Authenticity

Another crucial aspect of the court's ruling was the requirement for parties to demonstrate the relevance and authenticity of the social media content they seek to access. Mere speculation or fishing expeditions are not sufficient grounds for requesting disclosure. Instead, the requesting party must provide a compelling argument as to why the content is directly related to the case.

Furthermore, the court emphasized the importance of verifying the authenticity of the content. In an era where digital manipulation is increasingly sophisticated, parties must ensure that the social media posts and photographs they present as evidence are genuine and unaltered.

Protecting Privacy

While the Ontario Superior Court acknowledged the potential relevance of social media content in personal injury cases, it also reaffirmed the importance of protecting individuals' privacy rights. It cautioned against using disclosure requests as a means of accessing personal and unrelated information.

To strike a balance between disclosure and privacy, the court recommended the use of third-party experts who can review social media content and redact irrelevant or private information before it is presented in court. This approach aims to safeguard privacy while still allowing relevant evidence to be considered.

Implications for Personal Injury Cases in Ontario

The ruling by the Ontario Superior Court serves as a significant milestone in the evolving landscape of personal injury law. It underscores the need for legal practitioners to adapt to the digital age, where social media has become an integral part of many people's lives. It also emphasizes the importance of careful and considered requests for social media disclosure, promoting a more targeted and fair approach.

For individuals pursuing personal injury claims, this ruling serves as a reminder to exercise caution on social media platforms during litigation. What you post can have implications for your case, and even seemingly unrelated content can be subject to scrutiny if it is deemed relevant.

Ontario Superior Court's ruling on social media disclosure requests in personal injury cases highlights the delicate balance between privacy and relevance. While it acknowledges the potential importance of social media content as evidence, it also emphasizes the need to protect individuals' privacy rights. This ruling sets a precedent for future cases and underscores the importance of a thoughtful and proportionate approach to social media disclosure in the context of personal injury litigation in Ontario, Canada.

Have you Been Injured in an Accident?

Contacting the experienced personal injury lawyers at Deutschmann Personal Injury and Disability Law is crucial for ensuring that your legal rights are protected and that you receive the compensation you deserve in the event of an injury. Their deep expertise and dedication to advocating for their clients make them a trusted resource for those seeking justice and fair compensation in personal injury cases.

About Deutschmann Law

Deutschmann Law serves South-Western Ontario with offices in Kitchener-Waterloo, Cambridge, Woodstock, Brantford, Stratford and Ayr. The law practice of Robert Deutschmann focuses almost exclusively in personal injury and disability insurance matters. For more information, please visit www.deutschmannlaw.com or call us at 1-519-742-7774.

It is important that you review your accident benefit file with one of our experienced personal injury / car accident lawyers to ensure that you obtain access to all your benefits which include, but are limited to, things like physiotherapy, income replacement benefits, vocational retraining and home modifications.